Give every number a next step
An enrollment report can be full of information and still leave the team wondering what to do on Monday. In this Visiting Artisan conversation, Will Patch brings the work back to a practical sequence: what, so what, now what. Name the observation, explain its context, then identify a useful action. The sequence gives a report a purpose beyond arriving in someone's inbox.
His example is deliberately simple. Applications rising 15% sounds encouraging until you learn how comparable institutions are doing. A peer group rising 25% prompts a different discussion from one falling 15%. Those comparisons still need matching periods and definitions. They help frame a question; they do not explain the cause of the change. A useful next step might be checking which programs or inquiry sources account for the movement before changing a campaign.
In the recording · 07:25 ↗Make room for the person who checks the answer
Will identifies two linked barriers to insight: people and time. A curious colleague who can investigate the data is valuable, but assigning that person another report without removing anything from their workload does not create analytical capacity. Decide what work can wait, who will review the result and which decision the analysis is supposed to support.
The final gut check belongs in that allocation of time. Does the result make sense? Is the population correct? Could one filter have changed the whole answer? A tidy chart cannot answer those questions for you. Pair the numerical review with someone who understands the work represented by the records, and keep enough detail available to trace an unexpected result.
In the recording · 08:51 ↗Audit the value of the message
The conversation's four-P lens sorts outreach into personalized and relevant, process-based, promotional, and pointless messages. Will builds on a three-P framework shared with him by a colleague, adding the fourth category after observing messages that offer little value or reach the wrong audience. The point is to give a team language for improving its work without attacking the people who made it.
In the secret-shopping work he discusses, process messages accounted for 45% of outreach, personalized and relevant messages 20%, promotional messages 19%, and pointless messages 16%. Those figures describe the exercise he is discussing. They are not a universal distribution or a prescribed formula for your communication plan. Use them to ask what your own audience receives and what those messages help someone understand.
Start with a routine check-in. What information would make it worth opening? Will's biology example offers a concrete answer: show students doing fieldwork in a local stream and invite the reader to confirm whether that academic interest still fits. The message can introduce a distinctive experience, answer a question and open a conversation. Combining purposes works best when the reader can still recognize one clear next step.
In the recording · 11:23 ↗Check the front door before adding more outreach
An inquiry form is a small but consequential part of that conversation. Will describes institutions where it was difficult to find a form or where an inquiry received no response. A prospective student should not need an admissions professional's vocabulary to ask for help. Start on a common landing page and see how readily someone can raise a hand.
Then follow the request all the way through. Is the form asking only for information needed at this stage? Does the response acknowledge the person's question? Is a useful reply reaching a person or an unattended queue? Collecting more detail later can keep the first step manageable. A better subject line will not repair a broken path from interest to assistance.
In the recording · 18:13 ↗Give the team permission to stop
Will's culture of optimization depends on testing, sharing what was learned and being willing to retire work that is no longer useful. That last step matters when staff are already stretched. Every new tool, message and report consumes time; a team that only adds work has less room to understand whether any of it helps.
Choose one bounded experiment rather than rebuilding the whole communication plan. State the question, identify an appropriate comparison, decide how to judge the result and set a review date. Keep essential deadline and support information available. Share the findings with colleagues who can apply them elsewhere, including the possibility that the original approach performed better.
The opening conversation about Will's cooking notebooks makes this habit tangible: record what changed so the next attempt can learn from it. Carry that discipline into the enrollment office. Leave the review with a documented decision to keep, revise or stop one piece of work, plus a student question the next version will answer more clearly.
In the recording · 22:18 ↗